PROTECTION AGAINST MATRIMONIAL CRUELTY U/S 498-A, INDIAN PENAL CODE, 1860: SHIELD OR WEAPON
CRUELTY MEANING : According to SECTION 13[1][ia], Hindu
Marriage Act, the concept of cruelty has
varied from time to time along with a change
in social and economic conditions. Scolding
and nagging and even compatibility of
temperament have been held to be cruelty. No
precise definition of cruelty is there in any
book or statute, because cruelty may be
subtle or brutal or physical or mental. The
social conditions, the social status and
parties, the nature of the parties, financial
conditions of the parties also effect when
cruelty is defined. In cruelty the petitioner
has to prove that it is a cruel act and it
hampers the physical and mental condition of
the petitioner. It is necessary to prove to the
court that it is impossible to live with the
respondent in future after the act of cruelty is
done by the partner. The relation in between
them is not remained such that they can live
with each other without any mental stress.
Matrimonial cruelty:
In matrimonial life,
cruelty can be defined in many ways or
situations because it depends on person to
person or the socio-economic conditions.
Matrimonial cruelty can be:
1. Physical cruelty
2. Mental cruelty
SECTION 498-A, IPC: 'Whoever, being the
husband or the relative of the husband of a
woman, subjects such woman to cruelty shall
be punished with imprisonment for a term
which may extend to three years and shall
also be liable to fine.' For this section, cruelty
means:
1. Any willful conduct which is of such a nature
which is likely to drive the woman to commit
suicide or any grave injury or damage to her
life [mental or physical] of the woman, or
2. Harassment of the woman where such
harassment is with a view coercing her or any
person related to her to meet any unlawful
demand for any property or valuable security
or is on account of failure by her or any
person related to her to meet such demand. 1
The offence under this section is cognizable,
non-compoundable, and non-bailable. This
provision has been made to protect females
for domestic violence due to dowry [the
durable goods, cash, and real or movable
property that the bride’s family gives to the
bridegroom, his parents, or his relatives as the
condition for the marriage]. In India 24,771
dowry deaths have been reported in the last
three years, according to the National Crime
Bureau.
India is a country which is blessed to have
many Rites, Rituals & Customs which have a
considerable effect on all Indian societies.
Dowry was one of the practices which have
been and which are triumphing in India for a
large amount of time. Initially, this practice
turned into a dealt with as a blessing, but
unexpectedly this practice became a curse for
the society and the ladies fell prey of the
greed of their husbands and his family.
Therefore, for the safety of ladies, the
Government of India inserted Section 498A,
IPC by the change Act 1983. However, once
in a while this very provision of the law
which is supposed to be ameliorative will
become a source of harassment. Soon,
Section 498A, IPC became infamous for its
misuse. The National Crime Records Bureau
2012 record demonstrates the extent to which
the section is being misused. As per the
reports, the price of fee-sheeting turned into
excessive as 93.6% while the conviction rate
was as low as 15%. This segment has created
the biggest downside in a completely cutting
edge scenario for men as well for his family
as false allegations can bring humiliation to the family and can harm their reputation. In
many cases, men have even dedicated suicide
because the false allegation introduced an
awful lot humiliation to the family. The
debate surrounding Section 498A, IPC is
taking vicinity inside the area of criminal law
for far too long. Fundamentally, the debate
centres on the following parameters: Is there
any misuse of Section 498A? Has its outlived
its software? Are there any safeguards which
might be required to be constructed into
Section 498A to introduce its vital checks and
balances? Through this research paper, I try
to compare the judicial developments in
Section 498A IPC, that could assist us to
understand why there, is a misuse of Section
498A, IPC and why it has become an
essential evil and what steps have been
recommended to minimize its misuse.


